Suggestions by @subtlycharmingdream

Angela Bassett

as Winnie Guster in Psych

Score: +1

Queen Latifah

as Winnie Guster in Psych

Score: +1

Viola Davis

as Winnie Guster in Psych

Score: +1

JD McCrary

as Young Gus in Psych

Score: +1

Miles Brown

as Young Gus in Psych

Score: +1

Jahi Di'Allo Winston

as Young Gus in Psych

Score: +1

Jenny Slate

as Yang in Psych

Score: +1

Sarah Silverman

as Yang in Psych

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Yang in Psych

Score: +2

Odette Annable

as Abigail in Psych

Score: +2

Nina Dobrev

as Abigail in Psych

Score: +4

Ana de Armas

as Abigail in Psych

Score: +2

Hugh Skinner

as Mary in Psych

Score: 0

Jeremy Irvine

as Mary in Psych

Score: 0

Lee Norris

as Mary in Psych

Score: +1

Cate Blanchett

as Madeleine Spencer in Psych

Score: +3

Nicole Kidman

as Madeleine Spencer in Psych

Score: +1

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Madeleine Spencer in Psych

Score: +1

Jacob Tremblay

as Shawn in Psych

Score: +1

William Franklyn-Miller

as Shawn in Psych

Score: -1