Suggestions by @stormszee

Anne Hathaway

as Patricia Tannis in Borderlands Movie

Score: +3

Steve Zahn

as Scooter in Borderlands Movie

Score: +2

Florian Munteanu

as Krieg in Borderlands Movie

Score: +3

Ryan Kwanten

as Scooter in Borderlands Movie

Score: -1

Benjamin Byron Davis

as Marcus in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Knoxx in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as Jakobs in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Simon Pegg

as Hammerlock in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Christina Hendricks

as Moxxi in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Emma Myers

as Tiny Tina in Borderlands Movie

Score: +2

Carice van Houten

as Moxxi in Borderlands Movie

Score: -2

Teagan Croft

as Tiny Tina in Borderlands Movie

Score: -1

Keala Settle

as Ellie in Borderlands Movie

Score: +2

Jena Malone

as Lilith in Borderlands Movie

Score: 0

Scarlett Johansson

as Lilith in Borderlands Movie

Score: 0

Eva Green

as Moxxi in Borderlands Movie

Score: +2

Aubrey Plaza

as Patricia Tannis in Borderlands Movie

Score: +3

Christina Ricci

as Moxxi in Borderlands Movie

Score: -1

Ryan Redmond

as Ellie in Borderlands Movie

Score: +1

Rebecca Hall

as Patricia Tannis in Borderlands Movie

Score: -1