Suggestions by @steve23

Liev Schreiber

as Ben Grimm / The Thing in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Ewan McGregor

as Ben Grimm / The Thing in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +1

Sam Worthington

as Ben Grimm / The Thing in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +4

John Cena

as Ben Grimm / The Thing in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: 0

Zac Efron

as Johnny Storm / Human Torch in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +1

Ross Lynch

as Johnny Storm / Human Torch in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Rudy Pankow

as Johnny Storm / Human Torch in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Joe Keery

as Johnny Storm / Human Torch in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Lily James

as Sue Storm / The Invisible Woman in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Blake Lively

as Sue Storm / The Invisible Woman in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: 0

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Sue Storm / The Invisible Woman in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +1

Jodie Comer

as Sue Storm / The Invisible Woman in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +3

Emily Blunt

as Sue Storm / The Invisible Woman in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +1

Andrew Lincoln

as Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Matt Bomer

as Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +4

Patrick Wilson

as Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +1

Penn Badgley

as Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: -1

John Krasinski

as Reed Richards / Mr. Fantastic in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: 0

Michael Shannon

as Dr. Curt Connors in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2

Tom Cavanagh

as Dr. Curt Connors in Spider-Man Brand New Day (2026)

Score: +2