Suggestions by @stabhead2021

Jon Heder

as Dwayne Baker in Stab 4

Score: +1

Jonah Hill

as Marty in Stab 4

Score: +1

Kerr Smith

as Coach Barnes in Stab 4

Score: +1

Chad Michael Murray

as Jack Harmon in Stab 4

Score: +2

Ryan Merriman

as David Hughes in Stab 4

Score: +3

Linda Cardellini

as Claire Tate in Stab 4

Score: +1

Dee Wallace

as Mrs. Avery in Stab 4

Score: +1

Lacey Chabert

as Rachel Bates in Stab 4

Score: +1

Corbin Bleu

as Trevor Crossland in Stab 4

Score: +1

Mischa Barton

as Heather Watts in Stab 4

Score: +1

Ashton Kutcher

as Tyler Jennings in Stab 4

Score: +1

Amanda Seyfried

as Madison Rutledge in Stab 4

Score: +1

Amanda Bynes

as Summer Davis in Stab 4

Score: +1

Christopher Speed

as Randy Meeks in Stab 4

Score: +1

Shantel VanSanten

as Ashley Prescott in Stab 4

Score: +1

Tori Spelling

as Sidney Prescott in Stab 4

Score: +1

Janet Jackson

as Bianca in Stab 3

Score: 0

Ryan Phillippe

as Tom Prinze in Stab 3

Score: 0

Ali Larter

as Christine Hamilton in Stab 3

Score: 0

Milla Jovovich

as Jennifer Jolie in Stab 3

Score: 0