Suggestions by @spencersumwalt

T.J. Miller

as Phil in Aurora

Score: +1

Oleg Taktarov

as Zielinski in Aurora

Score: -1

Alexandra Park

as Ann-Sophie in Aurora

Score: +1

Ed Skrein

as Marcian in The Devils, by Joe Abercrombie

Score: +6

Andy Serkis

as Frigo in The Devils, by Joe Abercrombie

Score: +3

Meera Syal

as Cardinal Bock in The Devils, by Joe Abercrombie

Score: +2

Carrie-Anne Moss

as Bishop Apollonia in The Devils, by Joe Abercrombie

Score: +3

Tom Hopper

as Marcian in The Devils, by Joe Abercrombie

Score: +1

Rupert Friend

as Brady in Aurora

Score: +1

Corey Hawkins

as Perry St. John in Aurora

Score: +1

Stephen Dorff

as Rusty in Aurora

Score: +1

Cliff Curtis

as Marques in Aurora

Score: +1

James Cromwell

as Norman Levy in Aurora

Score: +1

Anthony Michael Hall

as Thom Banning in Aurora

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Scott in Aurora

Score: +1

Aubrey Plaza

as Aubrey Wheeler in Aurora

Score: +1

Rahul Kohli

as Hamish in The Staircase in the Woods

Score: -1

Peter A. Hulne

as Hamish in The Staircase in the Woods

Score: -2

Johnny Galecki

as Owen in The Staircase in the Woods

Score: -1

Noah Centineo

as Matty in The Staircase in the Woods

Score: +1