Suggestions by @spencerfirman

Michael Fassbender

as Emhyr var Emreis in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: +1

Hollywoodedge, Baby Moaning Pleasur PE144501

as Emhyr var Emreis in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: -1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Triss Merigold in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Ciri in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: +1

Kate Beckinsale

as Yennefer of Vengerburg in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: +1

Mads Mikkelsen

as Geralt of Rivia in HBO’s The Witcher

Score: +1

Alec Guinness

as Sam Loomis in Halloween (1988-2019)

Score: +1

Peter Weller

as Sam Loomis in Halloween (1988-2019)

Score: +2

Adam Scott

as Lt. Kif Kroker in Futurama

Score: +2

Bill Burr

as Bender B. Rodriguez in Futurama

Score: -1

Sam Rockwell

as Bender B. Rodriguez in Futurama

Score: 0