Suggestions by @sparkyyoungupstart

Avan Jogia

as Gideon Jura in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Khary Payton

as Ajani Goldmane in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Saoirse Ronan

as Elspeth Tirel in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Daisy Ridley

as Elspeth Tirel in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +2

Naomi Scott

as Elspeth Tirel in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Connor Swindells

as Tyvar Kell in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Nicole Maines

as Vraska in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Lucas Hedges

as Tezzeret in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: -1

David Tennant

as Tezzeret in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Lewis Tan

as Sarkhan Vol in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +2

Matthew Mercer

as Nicol Bolas in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: 0

Dove Cameron

as Liliana Vess in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Megan Fox

as Liliana Vess in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Jessica Henwick

as Nissa Revane in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +2

Adelaide Kane

as Nissa Revane in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +1

Theo James

as Gideon Jura in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: +2

Mandip Gill

as Chandra Nalaar in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: -1

Elliot Fletcher

as Jace Beleren in Magic the Gathering - Gatewatch

Score: 0

Jamie Clayton

as Vraska in Magic The Gathering:Revival

Score: +1

Elliot Fletcher

as Jace Beleren in Magic The Gathering:Revival

Score: +1