Suggestions by @something_ig

Neve Campbell

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: +3

Natasha Lyonne

as Max Mayfield in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: +1

Charlie Cox

as Will Byers in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: -1

Alan Ritchson

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: -1

Anthony Mackie

as Lucas Sinclair in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: -1

Bill Hader

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: -1

Natalie Portman

as Eleven Hopper in Stranger Things: The Return

Score: +3