Suggestions by @someetramay

Emmy Rossum

as Lois Lane in Superman: Man of Tomorrow

Score: -1

Henry Cavill

as Clark Kent in Superman: Man of Tomorrow

Score: +4

Christoph Waltz

as Victor Sullivan in Allan Ungar's Uncharted

Score: -1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Rafe Adler in Allan Ungar's Uncharted

Score: +5

Alan Ritchson

as Rafe Adler in Allan Ungar's Uncharted

Score: -1

Jon Bernthal

as KGBeast in Batman

Score: 0

Christoph Waltz

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman

Score: -1

Stephen Amell

as Bruce Wayne in Batman

Score: -22

Henry Cavill

as Bruce Wayne in Batman

Score: -20