Suggestions by @solamander1234

Julia Roberts

as Melissa Edgley in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Kevin Costner

as Baron Vengeous in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Baron Vengeous in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +3

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Melancholia St. Clair in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

AnnaSophia Robb

as Clarabelle in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Evanna Lynch

as Clarabelle in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +3

David McCallum

as Kenspeckle Grouse in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -1

Johnny Depp

as Spring-Heeled Jack in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +3

Hugh Jackman

as Saracen Rue in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +2

Theo James

as Dexter Vex in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Anton Shudder in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Josh Henderson

as Billy-Ray Sanguine in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -2

Vin Diesel

as Mr. Bliss in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +3

Liv Tyler

as China Sorrows in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -1

Amber Heard

as Tanith Low in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -2

Mark Hamill

as Bucky Barnes in Captain America: The First Avenger (1981)

Score: +4

Amanda Seyfried

as Rapunzel in Live Action Disney Characters

Score: -1

Russell Brand

as Captain Hook in Live Action Disney Characters

Score: +1

Kathy Bates

as Ursula in Live Action Disney Characters

Score: +3

Brenda Song

as Fa Mulan in Live Action Disney Characters

Score: -1