Suggestions by @sofly

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Director in Company

Score: +1

Skylar Astin

as Paul in Company

Score: +1

Beanie Feldstein

as Marta/PJ in Company

Score: +1

Beanie Feldstein

as Jenny in Company

Score: +1

Joanna Lumley

as Joanne in Company

Score: +1

Christine Baranski

as Joanne in Company

Score: +2

Luke Evans

as Anthony Marston in And Then There Were None

Score: +1

Olivia Colman

as Emily Brent in And Then There Were None

Score: +1

Jacob Artist

as Don Kerr in A Chorus Line Live!

Score: +1

Susan Sarandon

as Jaqueline Kennedy Onassis in American Love Story

Score: +2

Alia Shawkat

as Madelyn Pugh in Lucy and Desi

Score: +2

Jake Lacy

as Bob Carroll, Jr. in Lucy and Desi

Score: +2

Nina Arianda

as Vivian Vance in Lucy and Desi

Score: +3

J.K. Simmons

as William Frawley in Lucy and Desi

Score: +2

Javier Bardem

as Desi Arnaz in Lucy and Desi

Score: +3

Nicole Kidman

as Lucille Ball in Lucy and Desi

Score: +2

Drew Barrymore

as Actress in Actors / actresses / who need to be in the Knives Out sequence

Score: +9

Betty White

as Actress in Actors / actresses / who need to be in the Knives Out sequence

Score: +2

Angela Lansbury

as Cameo in Actors / actresses / who need to be in the Knives Out sequence

Score: +6

Prince

as Vocalist (male) in Most Attractive Celebrities (People of Color Edition)

Score: +3