Suggestions by @soda1459

Tessa Thompson

as Khaliset in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Ezra Miller

as Ezio Auditore (young) in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Justin Theroux

as Nikolaos in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Kevin Costner

as Charles Lee in Assassin's Creed

Score: -2

Matthew McConaughey

as Samuel Adams in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Marwan Kenzari

as Yusuf Tazim in Assassin's Creed

Score: +2

Naveen Andrews

as Jubair in Assassin's Creed

Score: 0

Numan Acar

as Majd Addin in Assassin's Creed

Score: +2

Gary Oldman

as David Brewster in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Bruce Dern

as Jacopo de' Pazzi in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Carl Weathers

as Achilles Davenport in Assassin's Creed

Score: +9

Johnny Depp

as Jack the Ripper in Assassin's Creed

Score: 0

Margot Robbie

as Lucrezia Borgia in Assassin's Creed

Score: +15

Michael Madsen

as Louis-Joseph Gaultier, chevalier de la Vérendrye in Assassin's Creed

Score: +2

Kurt Russell

as George Washington in Assassin's Creed

Score: +4

Jean Dujardin

as Louis-Joseph Gaultier, chevalier de la Vérendrye in Assassin's Creed

Score: +4

Lyriq Bent

as Jack Weeks in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Channing Tatum

as Liam O'Brien in Assassin's Creed

Score: +3

Shemar Moore

as Le Chasseur in Assassin's Creed

Score: 0