Suggestions by @soda1459

Jeff Daniels

as Mario Auditore in Assassin's Creed

Score: 0

Ben Foster

as Sibrand in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Tom Hardy

as Jack the Ripper in Assassin's Creed

Score: +2

Stephen Graham

as Checco Orsi in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Vincent Piazza

as Vieri de' Pazzi in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Rebecca Crane in Assassin's Creed

Score: +2

Simon Pegg

as Shaun Hastings in Assassin's Creed

Score: +7

Michael Shannon

as Haytham Kenway in Assassin's Creed

Score: 0

Toby Kebell

as Jacob Frye in Assassin's Creed

Score: -3

Jeff Daniels

as Mario Auditore in Assassin's Creed

Score: +3

Matthew McConaughey

as Ivarr Ragnarsson in Assassin's Creed

Score: +1

Charlie Hunnam

as Eivor (male) in Assassin's Creed

Score: +5

Shia LaBeouf

as Sam Trapani in Mafia

Score: +1

Robert De Niro

as Ennio Salieri in Mafia

Score: +5

Colin Farrell

as Tommy Angelo in Mafia

Score: +8

Jason Clarke

as Joe Barbaro in Mafia

Score: +3

Zendaya

as Rosa Parks in World History

Score: -1

Stanley Tucci

as Harry S. Truman in World History

Score: +2