Suggestions by @smurphys_law

Tom Cruise

as Marty Mauser in Marty Supreme (1995)

Score: +10

Charlie Hunnam

as Jack O’Connell in Almost Cast: The Batman (2012)

Score: +3

Aidan Gillen

as Jeremy Strong in Almost Cast: The Batman (2012)

Score: +2

Ethan Hawke

as Oscar Isaac in Almost Cast: The Batman (2012)

Score: +2

David Harbour

as Two-Face in Batman Forever

Score: +7

Adrien Brody

as Two-Face in Batman Forever

Score: +4

Daniel Radcliffe

as The Riddler in Batman Forever

Score: +7

Yorgos Lanthimos

as Director in The Beatles' The Lord of the Rings

Score: +6

Denis Villeneuve

as Director in The Beatles' The Lord of the Rings

Score: +4

Alden Ehrenreich

as Liev Schreiber in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Ethan Hawke

as Chris Cooper in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Daniel Craig

as Sam Neill in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +3

Josh Brolin

as Ed Harris in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Lee Pace

as David Duchovny in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Sean Penn

as Robert De Niro in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Stephen Graham

as Brendan Gleeson in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +2

Nicolas Cage

as Christopher Walken in Almost Cast: Doctor Octopus

Score: +4

Ridley Scott

as Director in The Beatles: A Four-Film Cinematic Event (2008)

Score: +4

Penélope Cruz

as Joi in Blade Runner: 2049 (2007)

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as Officer KD6-3.7 in Blade Runner: 2049 (2007)

Score: +1