Suggestions by @sleepspell

Lorenzo Richelmy

as Willas Tyrell in A Song of Ice and Fire

Score: +6

Vito Basso

as Loras Tyrell in A Song of Ice and Fire

Score: -1

Jordan Rodrigues

as Iruka Umino in Naruto

Score: +1

Aedin Mincks

as Choji Akimichi in Naruto

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as Sollux Captor in Homestuck

Score: +1

Gabriel Santana

as Gamzee Makara in Homestuck

Score: +1

Akeem Osborne

as Karkat Vantas in Homestuck

Score: +2

Jacob Whiteduck-Lavoie

as Gamzee Makara in Homestuck

Score: +1

Daniel Padilla

as Karkat Vantas in Homestuck

Score: +2

Georgie Henley

as Jade Harley in Homestuck

Score: 0

Danny Griffin

as Dave Strider in Homestuck

Score: +1

Samantha Win

as Kurenai Yuhi in Naruto

Score: +1

Jessika Van

as Kurenai Yuhi in Naruto

Score: +1

Luke Prael

as Sollux Captor in Homestuck

Score: +2

Kiernan Shipka

as Rose Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: +3

Mckenna Grace

as Rose Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: +1

Teagan Croft

as Roxy Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: -1

Grace VanderWaal

as Rose Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: +2

Dane DeHaan

as Sollux Captor in Homestuck

Score: +1

Noah Schnapp

as John Egbert in Homestuck

Score: 0