Suggestions by @skully

Christopher Walken

as Kanikus in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +1

Jacob Batalon

as Garth Bravebark in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Atticus Follyscale in Truetail: the Movie

Score: 0

Nick Robinson

as Dylan Horn in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +2

Dove Cameron

as Melody Briar in Truetail: the Movie

Score: -2

Skai Jackson

as Harper Finch in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Ami in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +2

Tom Hiddleston

as Viktor Silvertod in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +1

Zendaya

as Thora in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Caleb Lightpaw in Truetail: the Movie

Score: +4

Callan McAuliffe

as Garret in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Noah Centineo

as Zach in Camp Blood

Score: +2

Logan Miller

as Terrence in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Sheriff Robinson in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Joey King

as Susan in Camp Blood

Score: +2

Maika Monroe

as Alice in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Madelaine Petsch

as Charlotte in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Sara in Camp Blood

Score: +1

Millie Bobby Brown

as Amy Ruthlins in Nightmare

Score: +2

Mandy Moore

as Beth Ruthlins in Nightmare

Score: +1