Suggestions by @skamos

Oscar Isaac

as Elias Bouchard in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -11

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Micheal in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: +16

a plastic mannequin

as Nikola Orsinov in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: +29

Noel Fielding

as Gerard Keay in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -4

Shelley Duvall

as Agnes Montague in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -2