Suggestions by @sitarabegum

Tyler Hoechlin

as Bizarro in Man of Steel Return

Score: +1

Peter Dinklage

as Mr. Mxyzptlk in Man of Steel Return

Score: +2

Emma Stone

as Livewire in Man of Steel Return

Score: +4

Terry Notary

as Titano in Man of Steel Return

Score: 0

Ray Stevenson

as General zod in Man of Steel Return

Score: +2

Tessa Thompson

as Silver Banshee in Man of Steel Return

Score: +3

Viggo Mortensen

as Mongul in Man of Steel Return

Score: 0

Justin Theroux

as Cyborg superman in Man of Steel Return

Score: +3

Ving Rhames

as Doomsday in Man of Steel Return

Score: +1

Bill Hader

as The Toyman in Man of Steel Return

Score: +2

Daniel Craig

as Metallo in Man of Steel Return

Score: +1

Tony Todd

as Parasite in Man of Steel Return

Score: +2

Ralph Fiennes

as Brainiac in Man of Steel Return

Score: +2

Patrick Stewart

as Lex luthor in Man of Steel Return

Score: 0

Jennifer Lawrence

as Supergirl (Kara Zor-El) in Man of Steel Return

Score: +1

Alice Eve

as Lois lane in Man of Steel Return

Score: 0

Oscar Isaac

as Superman (Clark Kent) in Man of Steel Return

Score: +3