Suggestions by @siddarthsid

Amber Heard

as Millie Calloway in The Housemaid (2015)

Score: +5

Milly Alcock

as Catherine Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights

Score: +4

Adam Driver

as The Creature in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +5

John Leguizamo

as Sensei Sergio St. Carlos in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Riley Keough

as Rachel Kemp in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Jessica Chastain

as Michelle Fuller in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +6

Richard Roundtree

as Delta Slim in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +4

Octavia Spencer

as Annie in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Cameron Diaz

as Claire Sardina in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +1

Rosamund Pike

as Agnes Shakespeare in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Janelle Monáe

as Perfidia Beverly Hills in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +1

James Woods

as Col. Steven J. Lockjaw in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Mahershala Ali

as Elijah "Smoke" Moore / Elias "Stack" Moore in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Bob Ferguson in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +3

Jesse Eisenberg

as Marty Mauser in 98th Academy Awards (2016)

Score: +2

Laura Harrier

as Perfidia Beverly Hills in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +3

Selton Mello

as Armando Solimões / Marcelo Alves / Fernando Solimões in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +3

Sarah Snook

as Michelle Fuller in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +5

Kate Bosworth

as Claire Sardina in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +3

Emma Mackey

as Agnes Shakespeare in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +4