Suggestions by @ shinchannohara

Kevin Bacon

as Green Goblin in Spider Man 2004

Marisa Tomei

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 3 (1987)

+4-1Score: +3

Thomas F. Wilson

as Johnny Lawrence in Cobra Kai (90's)

Hayden Christensen

as Steve Harrington in If the kids of Stranger Things were adults fancast

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Eddie Munson in If the kids of Stranger Things were adults fancast

Andrew Garfield

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things Cast as Adults

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Spider-Man in Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man Trilogy (2012 - 17)

+2-1Score: +1

Aaron Paul

as Max Dillon in Spider- Man MCU Fancast

+4-0Score: +4

Dacre Montgomery

as Flash Thompson in Spider- Man MCU Fancast

+8-0Score: +8

Krysten Ritter

as Felicia Hardy in Spider Man 4

Anne Hathaway

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider Man 4

Anne Hathaway

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 4 (2011)

Aaron Paul

as Electro in Spider-Man 4 (2009)

+4-1Score: +3

Anne Hathaway

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 4 (2009)

Norman Reedus

as The Punisher in Daredevil (2005-2008)

+4-1Score: +3

Martin Kove

as Sandman in Spider Man 1984s

Thomas F. Wilson

as Flash Thompson in Spider Man 1984s

Thomas F. Wilson

as Flash Thompson in Spider Man 1986