Suggestions by @sheydam

James McAvoy

as Ted Tonks in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Keira Knightley

as Andromeda Tonks in Marauders Era

Score: +2

Eva Green

as Walburga Black in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Colin Firth

as Orion Black in Marauders Era

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Fleamont Potter in Marauders Era

Score: +1

Elle Fanning

as Pandora Lovegood in Marauders Era

Score: +2

Maxence Danet-Fauvel

as Bartemius Crouch Jr. in Marauders Era

Score: +2

Anne Hathaway

as Euphemia Potter in Marauders Era

Score: +1

Sofia Bryant

as Mary Macdonald in Marauders Era

Score: +2

Louis Garrel

as Severus Snape in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Hugh Laughton-Scott

as Evan Rosier in Marauders Era

Score: +1

Dane DeHaan

as Peter Pettigrew in Marauders Era

Score: +1

Alicia Vikander

as Marlene Mckinnon in Marauders Era

Score: -1

Timothée Chalamet

as Regulus Black in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Zoë Kravitz

as Dorcas Meadowes in Marauders Era

Score: -3

Sophie Skelton

as Lily Evans in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Ben Barnes

as Sirius Black in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as James Potter in Marauders Era

Score: +4

Andrew Garfield

as Remus Lupin in Marauders Era

Score: +3

Ross Butler

as Joey Tribbiani in Friends Reboot (2020)

Score: -5