Suggestions by @shesanangryelf

Levi Miller

as Puck in Sisters Grimm

Score: +1

Brooklynn Prince

as Daphne Grimm in Sisters Grimm

Score: +2

Mckenna Grace

as Daphne Grimm in Sisters Grimm

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Red in Sisters Grimm

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Jason Dean in Heathers: The Musical

Score: +1

Storm Reid

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers: The Musical

Score: +3

Adjoa Andoh

as Mama Euralie in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Denée Benton

as Ti Moune in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Hailey Kilgore

as Ti Moune in Once on This Island

Score: +2

Isaac Powell

as Daniel Beauxhomme in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Daveed Diggs

as Armand Beauxhomme in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Nabiyah Be

as Erzulie in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Janelle Monáe

as Erzulie in Once on This Island

Score: +1

Taraji P. Henson

as Diane Goodman in Next to normal

Score: +1

Zaris-Angel Hator

as Natalie Goodman in Next to normal

Score: -3

Zendaya

as Natalie Goodman in Next to normal

Score: -4

Marsai Martin

as Wednesday Addams in The Addams Family

Score: -5

Sunny Pawar

as Bean in Ender's Shadow

Score: +1