Suggestions by @shesanangryelf

Janelle Monáe

as Lilith Iyapo in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Amandla Stenberg

as Nikanj in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Ezra Miller

as Nikanj in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: 0

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in Lord of Shadows

Score: 0

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in Mortal Instruments

Score: 0

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in Shadowhunters (recasted)

Score: -1

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in The mortal instruments reboot

Score: +1

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in The Mortal Instruments

Score: -2

Erin Kellyman

as Clary Fray in The Mortal Instruments

Score: -5

Erin Kellyman

as Rachel Elizabeth Dare in Heroes of Olympus: The Lost Hero

Score: +1

Gregory Díaz IV

as Leo Valdez in Heroes of Olympus: The Lost Hero

Score: -2

Eddie Redmayne

as Jdahya in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Thando Hopa

as Khione in Heroes of Olympus: The Lost Hero

Score: +2

Amandla Stenberg

as Tate in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Ezra Miller

as Tate in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Akie Kotabe

as Joseph in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Louis Ozawa Changchien

as Joseph in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Aja Naomi King

as Lilith Iyapo in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Jayme Lawson

as Lilith Iyapo in Dawn (Lilith's Brood) (Xenogenesis)

Score: +1

Charlotte Nicdao

as Drew Tanaka in Heroes of Olympus: The Lost Hero

Score: -3