Suggestions by @sephirothscout

Kris Zimmerman

as Director in Paper Mario 64 (Circa 2001)

Score: +1

Eminem

as Judas Iscariot in Jesus Christ Superstar Remake

Score: -1

Scott Wozniak

as Peter in Jesus Christ Superstar Remake

Score: +2

Jeremy Jordan

as Peter in Jesus Christ Superstar Remake

Score: +1

Adrienne Warren

as Mary Magdalene in Jesus Christ Superstar Remake

Score: +2

Sam Raimi

as Writer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

George Reinblatt

as Writer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

George Reinblatt

as Producer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Sam Raimi, Robert Tobert and Bruce Campbell

as Producer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Sam Raimi, Robert Tobert and Bruce Campbell

as Producer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as Producer in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as S-Mart Manager in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +2

Adrienne Warren

as Annie in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Scott Wozniak

as Ed in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Good Ol' Reliable Jake in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +2

Taylor Louderman

as Shelly in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Matt Doyle

as Scott in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Lena Hall

as Linda in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Barret Wilbert Weed

as Cheryl Williams in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as Ash Williams in Evil Dead: The Movie Musical

Score: +1