Suggestions by @sebastianmoreno

Javier Botet

as Pumpkinhead in Pumpkinhead: Rebirth

Score: +2

Robert Englund

as The Geryon Entity in KAOS Season 3

Score: +1

Gemma Chan

as Circe in KAOS Season 3

Score: +1

Kim Basinger

as Selene in KAOS Season 3

Score: +1

Doug Jones

as The Gill Man in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Javier Botet

as The Gill Man in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Elizabeth Henstridge

as Allison Trinity in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Isabelle Fuhrman

as Jill Jackson in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Noomi Rapace

as Wendy Carrigan in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Aaron Paul

as Rob Whitford in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Gemma Chan

as Rachel Lee in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Boyd Holbrook

as Dr. David Barton in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Scarlett Johansson

as Dr. Jerrica Stark in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Lupita Nyong'o

as Susan Hawkins in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Anthony Mackie

as Aaron Arnold in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +1

Jack Veal

as Ignatius Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Joseph Quinn

as Ignatius Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Rachel Hurd-Wood

as Cordelia Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Wunmi Mosaku

as Molly Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Sope Dirisu

as Drew G. Brown in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1