Suggestions by @seanbrewer
197 suggestions
Kiefer Sutherland
as Green Arrow in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: 0
Gerard Christopher
as Superman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: -1
Dean Cain
as Superman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: -1
Vin Diesel
as The Mutant Leader in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: +1
Billy Dee Williams
as Two Face in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: +1
Sean Bean
as Two Face in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: +2
Mark Harmon
as Batman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: 0
Jack Nicholson
as Joker in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Score: +3
Scott Bakula
as Green Lantern (cameo) in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +1
Kiefer Sutherland
as Green Arrow in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +1
Gerard Christopher
as Superman/Clark Kent/Kal-El in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +5
Dean Cain
as Superman/Clark Kent/Kal-El in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +1
Sam Elliott
as James Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +1
Sean Bean
as Two-Face/Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +1
Mark Harmon
as Batman/Bruce Wayne in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: 0
Michael Keaton
as Batman/Bruce Wayne in The Dark Knight Returns (Animated Alternate Cast)
Score: +4
River Phoenix
as Spider-Man in Avengers: Infinity War And Endgame (1988 And 1989)
Score: +1
Bill Murray
as Iron Man in Avengers: Infinity War And Endgame (1988 And 1989)
Score: -3
Dennis Quaid
as Captain America in Avengers: Infinity War And Endgame (1988 And 1989)
Score: -1
John Schneider
as Captain America in Avengers: Infinity War And Endgame (1988 And 1989)
Score: -2