Suggestions by @sariahcupp

Oliver Hudson

as Kurt O'Shea in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Jason Behr

as Marty Liam Gregory in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Keanu Reeves

as Rob Gogan in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

David Boreanaz

as Alistair Litten in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Ron Wilson in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Paul Rudd

as Colin Wilson in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Ryan Gosling

as Henry Shyres in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Paul Walker

as Norman Watson in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Cary Elwes

as Mr. Collins in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: 0

Skeet Ulrich

as Chris Hargensen in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: -1

Kevin Bacon

as Mark White in Carey 1998 (Carrie 1998 Genderswap)

Score: 0

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Paula Gardner in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: 0

Terry Crews

as Ron Wilson in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Katie Cassidy

as Danielle Brooks in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Penelope Riley in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Meryl Streep

as Willow Wexler in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

George Sear

as Seth Thomas in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Drew Starkey

as Ben Bates in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Nick Stabile

as Mitch Mancini in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Charlie McElveen

as Nathan Simons in Urban Legends 1998 (Genderswap)

Score: +2