Suggestions by @sarahfogg

Willem Dafoe

as The Merchant in Resident Evil 4

Score: +2

Ben Barnes

as Luis Sera in Resident Evil 4

Score: +2

Luke Evans

as Jack Krauser in Resident Evil 4

Score: +2

Tom Hardy

as Jack Krauser in Resident Evil 4

Score: +4

Peyton List

as Ashley Graham in Resident Evil 4

Score: -3

Dakota Fanning

as Ashley Graham in Resident Evil 4

Score: 0

Sabrina Carpenter

as Ashley Graham in Resident Evil 4

Score: -1

Dove Cameron

as Ashley Graham in Resident Evil 4

Score: -2

Lucy Liu

as Ada Wong in Resident Evil 4

Score: -3

Chris Hemsworth

as Leon Kennedy in Resident Evil 4

Score: -4

Chris Pine

as Leon Kennedy in Resident Evil 4

Score: -3

Richard Madden

as Leon Kennedy in Resident Evil 4

Score: -1

Mckenna Grace

as Kate Flax in Mermaids

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Joe in Mermaids

Score: +3

Alexander Ludwig

as Joe in Mermaids

Score: +3

Nick Robinson

as Joe in Mermaids

Score: +2

Daisy Ridley

as Charlotte Flax in Mermaids

Score: +1

Mark Hamill

as Lou Landsky in Mermaids

Score: -1