Suggestions by @saracuda

Benjamin (Fallout)

as Cyclops in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Tyson (Percy Jackson)

as Cyclops in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Percy Jackson

as Half-breed in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Michigan J. Frog

as Amphibian in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Tiana (Princess and the Frog)

as Amphibian in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Prince Naveen

as Amphibian in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Phinneus Pogo

as Ape in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Elphaba Thropp

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Elphaba

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Jake Sully

as Emergency Transformation in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Toula Portokalos (My Big Fat Greek Wedding)

as Fairytale Wedding Dress in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Giselle (Enchanted)

as Fairytale Wedding Dress in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Jennifer Oriana Stone (Cadet Kelly)

as Drill Sergeant Nasty in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

John Locke

as Dream-Crushing Handicap in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Dwayne Hoover

as Dream-Crushing Handicap in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Buffy Summers

as Barrier Maiden in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Lily Tucker-Pritchett

as Happily Adopted in Family Tropes

Score: +1

Rachel Berry

as Happily Adopted in Family Tropes

Score: +1

Sarah Miller

as Sarah in Best Characters with the Same Names

Score: +1

Annie James

as Long-Lost Relative in Family Tropes

Score: +1