Suggestions by @saracuda

Roald (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Puck (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Iggly (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Hopper (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Gwen (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Friga (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Flo (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Cube (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Chabwick (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Boomer (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Aurora (Animal Crossing)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Iceburgh (Pittsburgh Penguins)

as Penguin in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Joey (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Weber (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Scoot (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Quillson (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Pompom (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Pate (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Molly (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Miranda (Animal Crossing)

as Duck in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1