Suggestions by @sapphiremermaid

Tom Glynn-Carney

as Grayson Hawthorne in The Inheritance Games Series

Score: -3

Brian Dietzen

as John Casper in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

J.R. Ramirez

as David Gould in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

Billy Bob Thornton

as Jackson Sweet in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

Garcelle Beauvais

as Strata Luna in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

Kate Walsh

as Hollis Blake in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

Jaimie Alexander

as Elise Sandburg in Elise Sandburg Mysteries

Score: +1

Mae Whitman

as Iris in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Eva Longoria

as Chief Ortega in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Joey King

as Iris in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Clementine in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Dougie Baldwin

as Elliot in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Alex Høgh Andersen

as Leo in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Bonnie Bedelia

as Jenny Hanovarian in The Collector Series

Score: +1

Erika Christensen

as Cass Kearney in The Collector Series

Score: +1

Danny Pino

as Uriah Ashby in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Stana Katic

as Jude Fontaine in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Sam Jaeger

as Eric in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Cameron Douglas

as Adam Schilling in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1

Pierce Brosnan

as Governor Phillip Schilling in Jude Fontaine Mysteries

Score: +1