Suggestions by @samuelturner
417 suggestions
Dylan O'Brien
as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Tom Holland
as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Joe Keery
as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Katharine Isabelle
as Zelda Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Danielle Panabaker
as Zelda Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Danielle Harris
as Zelda Winston in Haddonwood Lake
Ansel Elgort
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Dominic Sherwood
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Cole Sprouse
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Tom Hardy
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Ben Hardy
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Jamie Campbell Bower
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Lucas Till
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Dan Stevens
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Austin Butler
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Aaron Taylor-Johnson
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Stephen Amell
as Samuel Phenyx/Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake
Ray Fisher
as Michael Hart in Haddonwood Lake
Zendaya Coleman
as Elena in Haddonwood Lake
Candice Patton
as Elena in Haddonwood Lake