Suggestions by @samuelturner

Tom Hardy

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Richard Madden

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Stephen Amell

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Tom Hardy

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Dwayne Johnson

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as Salem Hope/Samuel Phenyx in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jaden Smith

as Michael Hart in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Noah Centineo

as Garrett Sharpe in DSM

Score: 0

Jake T. Austin

as Garrett Sharpe in DSM

Score: +1

Claire Coffee

as Laurie Bishop in DSM

Score: +1

Kandyse McClure

as Laurie Bishop in DSM

Score: +1

Emily Deschanel

as Laurie Bishop in DSM

Score: +2

Bruce Campbell

as Manny Hanson in DSM

Score: +1

Katherine McNamara

as Kyla Pierce in DSM

Score: +1

Joe Keery

as Allen Hart in DSM

Score: +1

Ben Hardy

as Allen Hart in DSM

Score: +1

Dominic Sherwood

as Allen Hart in DSM

Score: +4