Suggestions by @samuelturner

Christian Slater

as Detective Eric Stephens in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Detective Eric Stephens in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jared Padalecki

as Detective Eric Stephens in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Detective Eric Stephens in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Zelda Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Danielle Harris

as Zelda Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Joe Keery

as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Dylan O'Brien

as Zachary Winston in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Selena Gomez

as Elena in Haddonwood Lake

Score: 0

Mila Kunis

as Elena in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Selena Gomez

as Elena in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Mila Kunis

as Elena in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Aimee Garcia

as Elena in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Mila Kunis

as Veronica Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Cobie Smulders

as Veronica Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Eva Green

as Veronica Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Lauren German

as Veronica Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Lauren Cohan

as Veronica Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1