Suggestions by @samuelturner

Dominic Sherwood

as Salem Hope in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as Samuel Phenyx (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Kevin Bacon

as Samuel Phenyx (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Samuel Phenyx (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jason Alexander

as Samuel Phenyx (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Samuel Phenyx (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Michelle Rodriguez

as Reaper Casey (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jennifer Lopez

as Reaper Casey (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Penélope Cruz

as Reaper Casey (Parallel Universe 2045) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Dominic Sherwood

as Samuel Phenyx (2010) in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +4

Emma Stone

as Peggy Brandt in The Mask (2020)

Score: +3

Lauren Cohan

as Kathy in The Mask (2020)

Score: 0

Ariel Winter

as Raven in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Camila Mendes

as Casey Fray in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jon Bernthal

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Will Smith

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Jamie Foxx

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: 0

Mahershala Ali

as Detective John Jackson in Haddonwood Lake

Score: +1