Suggestions by @saimarie

Willem Dafoe

as Abel Slaine in Forbidden Fantasies

Score: -1

Johnny Depp

as Abel Slaine in Forbidden Fantasies

Score: +1

Jennifer Tilly

as Lillith in Forbidden Fantasies

Score: +1

Sam Elliott

as Jesse Jessup in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Xochitl Gomez

as Rosalia Rodriguez in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Demi Lovato

as Rosalia Rodriguez in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Isabel May

as Ivanka Jessup in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Isabel May

as Caecelia Servili in Embracing His Empire

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as Oarxxas Vai'e in The Tales of Valisa

Score: +1

Joe Manganiello

as King Marcus in The Tales of Valisa

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Prince Irek in The Tales of Valisa

Score: +1

Sofía Vergara

as Queen Tri'Shena in The Tales of Valisa

Score: +1

Megan Fox

as Princess Analise in The Tales of Valisa

Score: +1

Jay Hernandez

as Antonio Rodriguez in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Selena Gomez

as Rosalia Rodriguez in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Jesse Jessup in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Susan Sarandon

as Margaret Jessup in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Alex Pettyfer

as Aaron Kilpatrick in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Claire Holt

as Ivanka Jessup in The Softer Side of Texas

Score: +1

Scott Eastwood

as Scotty in Forbidden Fantasies

Score: +1