Suggestions by @sadierobbins

Matt Bomer

as Wyatt in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: +1

Tom Payne

as Joe in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: 0

Isabelle Fuhrman

as Charlotte in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: +2

Lin Shaye

as Betty in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: -1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Calvin in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: +6

Amanda Seyfried

as Grace Evans in You Shouldn’t Have Come Here

Score: +10