Suggestions by @s_19_

Colin Ford

as Caspar in Caraval

Score: 0

Brandon Flynn

as Caspar in Caraval

Score: -2

Scott Eastwood

as Armando in Caraval

Score: 0

Andrew Garfield

as Armando in Caraval

Score: +2

Chris Evans

as Armando in Caraval

Score: -2

Mckenna Grace

as Donatella in Caraval

Score: -4

Peyton Elizabeth Lee

as Aiko in Caraval

Score: 0

Naomi Scott

as Aiko in Caraval

Score: 0

Jamie Chung

as Aiko in Caraval

Score: +2

Kiko Mizuhara

as Aiko in Caraval

Score: +2

James McAvoy

as Count Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Score: +1

Luke Evans

as Count Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as Count Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Score: -3

Michael Fassbender

as Count Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Score: -2

Henry Cavill

as Count Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Score: -1

Vanessa Redgrave

as Empress Elantine in Caraval

Score: +1

Julie Andrews

as Empress Elantine in Caraval

Score: +1

Helen Mirren

as Empress Elantine in Caraval

Score: +1

Keira Knightley

as Paloma in Caraval

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Paloma in Caraval

Score: -3