Suggestions by @ryderstone

Keanu Reeves

as Ares in Percy Jackson

Score: +1

Amy Adams

as Aphrodite in Percy Jackson

Score: +1

Jenn McAllister

as Player 067 in Squid Game USA Celebrities Edition

Score: +1

Ava Kris Tyson

as Player 120 in Squid Game USA Celebrities Edition

Score: +1

Ryan Trahan

as Player 333 in Squid Game USA Celebrities Edition

Score: +1

coryxkenshin

as Player 456 in Squid Game USA Celebrities Edition

Score: +2

Joe Davidson

as Willy Tybur in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Belle Henry

as Gabi Braun in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Bradley Cooper

as Kenny Ackermann in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Bryce Alakai

as Colt Grice in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Billy Magnussen

as Erwin Smith in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Skylar Gray

as Louise in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Isabella Leo

as Pieck Finger in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Dave Allen

as King Fritz in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Taj Cross

as Gunther Shultz in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Lucas Royalty

as Reiner Braun in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Aias Dalman

as Armin Arlert in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Avril Lena Wei

as Mikasa Ackermann in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1

Braxton Rodammer

as Eren Yeager in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: 0

Avril Lena Wei

as Mikasa Ackermann (Young) in Attack on Titan Live Action

Score: +1