Suggestions by @ryanjjacob

Josh Groban

as John Proctor in The Crucible

Lea Michele

as Irene Roth in Crazy for You: Live

Emma Stone

as Polly Baker in Crazy for You: Live

Ramin Karimloo

as Bela Zangler in Crazy for You: Live

Ben Platt

as Bobby Child in Crazy for You: Live

Lupita Nyong'o

as Cleopatra in Antony and Cleopatra

Henry Cavill

as Mark Antony in Antony and Cleopatra

Finn Wittrock

as Octavius Caesar in Antony and Cleopatra

Kathy Bates

as Blanche Hudson in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

Meryl Streep

as Baby Jane Hudson in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

Beyoncé

as Sheila in A Chorus Line

Kate Hudson

as Cassie in A Chorus Line

Ariana DeBose

as Diana in A Chorus Line

Anthony Ramos

as Paul in A Chorus Line

Zachary Levi

as Zach in A Chorus Line

Laura Linney

as Abigail Adams in The Presidency

Annette Bening

as Martha Washington in The Presidency

Paul Giamatti

as John Adams in The Presidency

Ralph Fiennes

as George Washington in The Presidency

Austin Butler

as Rapunzel's Prince in Into the Woods