Suggestions by @rwhite18

Anne Hathaway

as Arwen in Christopher Nolan's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Score: +3

Hugh Jackman

as Aragorn in Christopher Nolan's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Score: +2

Robert Pattinson

as Aragorn in Christopher Nolan's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Score: +4

Christian Bale

as Aragorn in Christopher Nolan's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Score: +1

Jessica Chastain

as Grace in Die My Love (2015)

Score: 0

Michelle Williams

as Grace in Die My Love (2015)

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Walter Burns in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

John Cho

as Walter Burns in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Hildy Johnson in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Hildy Johnson in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

Chris Pine

as Walter Burns in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Walter Burns in His Girl Friday (2020)

Score: +1

Shelley Duvall

as May Dove Canady in May (1972)

Score: +1

Ricky Schroder

as Stanley Spector in Magnolia (1979)

Score: +1

Paul Newman

as Jimmy Gator in Magnolia (1979)

Score: +1

Jeff Bridges

as Jim Kurring in Magnolia (1979)

Score: +1

Dustin Hoffman

as Quiz Kid Donnie Smith in Magnolia (1979)

Score: +1

Robert Duvall

as Phil Parma in Magnolia (1979)

Score: +1