Suggestions by @runilareads

Joseph Mazzello

as Chief McGinnis Jr. in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Laura Harrier

as Helen Corning in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Chris Potter

as Chief Collig in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Chief McGinnis in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Lana Condor

as Iola Morton in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +2

Noah Munck

as Chet Morton in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Angie Harmon

as Laura Hardy in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +3

Leslie Mann

as Trudy Hardy in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Ciara Bravo

as Callie Shaw in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +2

John Corbett

as Fenton Hardy in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Ansel Elgort

as Ned Nickerson in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Max Martini

as Carson Drew in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +1

Brianna Hildebrand

as George Fayne in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +4

Olivia Holt

as Bess Marvin in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +3

Skyler Gisondo

as Joe Hardy in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +3

Timothée Chalamet

as Frank Hardy in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +2

Katherine McNamara

as Nancy Drew in Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys

Score: +7