Suggestions by @runilareads

Blake Michael

as Todd Wilkins in Sweet Valley High

Score: +2

Lili Reinhart

as Elizabeth Wakefield/Jessica Wakefield in Sweet Valley High

Score: +1

William Moseley

as Captain Britain in Marvel

Score: +1

Alden Ehrenreich

as Justice in Marvel

Score: +1

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as The Wasp in Marvel

Score: +1

Gina Carano

as She-Hulk in Marvel

Score: +1

Aldis Hodge

as Black Panther in Marvel

Score: +1

Jamie Bell

as Spider-Man in Marvel

Score: +1

Jai Courtney

as Wolverine in Marvel

Score: +1

Grace Caroline Currey

as Shadowcat in Marvel

Score: +1

Allison Williams

as Shadowcat in Marvel

Score: +1

Rhys Matthew Bond

as Nightcrawler in Marvel

Score: +1

Ben Whishaw

as Nightcrawler in Marvel

Score: +1

Robbie Amell

as Colossus in Marvel

Score: +1

Courtney Halverson

as Firestar in Marvel

Score: +1

Patrick Wilson

as Giant-Man in Marvel

Score: +1

Grace Victoria Cox

as Invisible Woman in Marvel

Score: +1

Rose Byrne

as Invisible Woman in Marvel

Score: +2

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Doctor Doom in Marvel

Score: +1

Dylan Everett

as Human Torch in Marvel

Score: +3