Suggestions by @rstrange

Harry Shum Jr.

as James Reynolds in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +2

Kevin McHale

as Philip Hamilton in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +1

Jenna Ushkowitz

as Peggy Schuyler in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +2

Amber Riley

as Angelica Schuyler in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +3

Melissa Benoist

as Eliza Schuyler/Eliza Hamilton in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: -1

Naya Rivera

as Maria Reynolds in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +3

Darren Criss

as Aaron Burr in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +4

Jonathan Groff

as King George III in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +3

Chris Colfer

as King George III in Glee Cast as Hamilton Characters

Score: +1

Vanessa Morgan

as Marceline in Adventure Time

Score: -9

Greta Gerwig

as Director in Spring Awakening

Score: +2

Jaden Smith

as Marshall Lee in Adventure Time

Score: -6

Willow Smith

as Marceline in Adventure Time

Score: -6

Sofia Carson

as Angelina Jolie in Celebrity Biopics

Score: -2

Yara Shahidi

as Hilary Banks in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air (2019 Reboot)

Score: +3

Sydney Sweeney

as Persephone in Lore Olympus

Score: +1

Kodi Smit-McPhee

as Nightcrawler in MARVEL Cinematic Universe (MCU)

Score: -3

Taika Waititi

as Director in Actors Who Should Play Dr Seuss In A Biopic Movie

Score: +1

Taika Waititi

as Dr. Seuss in Actors Who Should Play Dr Seuss In A Biopic Movie

Score: +2

Michaela Jaé Rodriguez

as Wanda Mann in The Sandman

Score: +3