Suggestions by @ robynrichmond

Ben Platt

as Elder Cunningham in The Book of Mormon

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Moon Knight in Midnight Sons

+1-4Score: -3

John Goodman

as Paul Cicero in Goodfellas (10's)

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Tommy DeVito in Goodfellas (10's)

+3-3Score: 0

Zac Efron

as Henry Hill in Goodfellas (10's)

Barrett Wilbert Weed

as Roger Davis in Rent (Genderswap)

+1-2Score: -1

Mariah Rose Faith Casillas

as Roger Davis in Rent (Genderswap)

+6-0Score: +6

Lena Hall

as Angel Dumott Schunard in Rent (Genderswap)

Eva Noblezada

as Mark Cohen in Rent (Genderswap)

Darren Criss

as Mimi Marquez in Rent (Genderswap)

Victor Garber

as Professor Callahan in Legally Blonde Live

+1-0Score: +1

John Barrowman

as Professor Callahan in Legally Blonde Live

Darren Criss

as Warren Huntington III in Legally Blonde Live

+5-1Score: +4

Jonathan Groff

as Emmet Forrest in Legally Blonde Live

Christine Baranski

as Paulette Buonafonte in Legally Blonde Live

Ryan McCartan

as Warren Huntington III in Legally Blonde Live

+4-3Score: +1

Holt McCallany

as Victor fries/ mr freeze in Supporting Batman characters

David Harbour

as Victor fries/ mr freeze in Supporting Batman characters