Suggestions by @ringohulk777

Tony Shalhoub

as Bruce Banner/Hulk (recast) in MCU Phase 1-3 (1998-2009)

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Grima Wormtongue in Lord of the Rings TV Series

Score: 0

Keanu Reeves

as Silver Surfur in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: 0

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Zelda/Sheik in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: +1

Ron Perlman

as Bowser in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: +2

James Earl Jones

as Ganondorf in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: +2

Goldie Hawn

as Princess Peach in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: -1

James Marsden

as Ganondorf in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: -1

Whoopi Goldberg

as Jigglypuff in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: +1

Sylvester Stallone

as Captain Falcon in 80's/90's fancast Super Smash Bros

Score: +2

Micky Dolenz

as Edward Nygma in Burtonverse

Score: -2

Tim Curry

as Scarecrow in Batman Forever (Tim Burton Version)

Score: +5

Micky Dolenz

as Riddler in Batman Forever (Tim Burton Version)

Score: 0

Jack Nicholson

as Doctor Doom in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: -2

James Earl Jones

as Galactus in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: +2

Carrie Fisher

as Invisible Woman in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: 0

Tom Cruise

as Human Torch in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: +3

Harrison Ford

as Thing in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: -3

Harold Ramis

as Mr. Fantastic in 80's Fantastic 4 fancast

Score: +7

Tom Hanks

as Scott Lang in Marvel Cinematic Universe (1980s)

Score: +1