Suggestions by @redqueenseries

Erika Prevost

as Kassie in High School

Alison Thornton

as Fiona in High School

Mckenna Grace

as Fiona in High School

Kathryn Newton

as Fiona in High School

Chloe Lukasiak

as Jessie in High School

Veronica Dunne

as Jessie in High School

Maddie Ziegler

as Jessie in High School

Brielle Barbusca

as Melissa in High School

Melise

as Melissa in High School

Jenna Ortega

as Melissa in High School

Nikki Hahn

as Melissa in High School

Leah Lewis

as Melissa in High School

Lily D. Moore

as Richelle in High School

Avi Lake

as Isabelle in High School

Malina Weissman

as Isabelle in High School

Lia Marie Johnson

as Candance in High School

Allie DeBerry

as Candance in High School

Stefanie Scott

as Candance in High School

Lilly Aspell

as Anny in High School

Madison Iseman

as Anny in High School