Suggestions by @reclaimer
3,225 suggestions
John C. Reilly
as Dudley Frazier in Animal Man
John C. Reilly
as Detective Karl Krenshaw in Animal Man
Paul Giamatti
as Detective Karl Krenshaw in Animal Man
Harry Styles
as Nowhere Man in Animal Man
Mark Addy
as Roger Huntoon in Animal Man
Liam Hemsworth
as Bernhard "Buddy" Baker in Animal Man
Vanessa Hudgens
as Zatanna Zatara in Justice League: The Musical
Victoria Justice
as Zatanna Zatara in Justice League: The Musical
Benjamin Walker
as Bruce Wayne in Justice League: The Musical
T.V. Carpio
as Diana Prince in Justice League: The Musical
Damon Daunno
as Patrick "Eel" O'Brien in Justice League: The Musical
Billy Magnussen
as Oliver Queen in Justice League: The Musical
Eva Noblezada
as Diana Prince in Justice League: The Musical
Zac Efron
as Barry Allen in Justice League: The Musical
Billy Magnussen
as Clark Kent in Justice League: The Musical
Tom Feeney
as Arthur Curry in Justice League: The Musical
Reeve Carney
as Barry Allen in Justice League: The Musical
Andrew Garfield
as Rusty McCoy in Starlight Express
Maggie Levin
as Director in Starlight Express
Maggie Levin
as Director in Diamond Dogs