Suggestions by @rebekahshoemaker2025

Ricky Gervais

as Drew in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Ashley Nichols

as Starlight in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Michael 'Lippy' Lipman

as Nightmare Rabbit/Nutty in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Aiden in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Lamby in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Flakie in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Isla Fisher

as Petunia in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Ian in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Tanjiro Kamado

as Luigi in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Mike Salcedo

as Bentley in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Mike Salcedo

as Victor in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Kristen Bell

as Daisy in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Idina Menzel

as Rosalina in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Tom Kenny

as Warren in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Lady Tamayo

as Molly in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Pete Davidson

as Lucky in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Nezuko Kamado

as Ella/Elliana in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Micheal Kovach as Jax - The Amazing Digital Circus

as Homer in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Warren Graff

as Tom in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1

Kenn Navarro

as Ryan in Nightmare Gen Friends

Score: +1