Suggestions by @ratjesus

Winona Ryder

as Sklonda Gukgak in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Letitia Wright

as Ayda Aguefort in Fantasy High

Score: +3

Letitia Wright

as Ayda Aguefort in Fantasy High

Score: +2

Jenna Ortega

as Figueroth Faeth in Fantasy High

Score: +4

Xochitl Gomez

as Tracker O'shaughnessey in Fantasy High

Score: +3

Xochitl Gomez

as Tracker O'Shaughnessey in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Freya Allan

as Adaine Abernant in Fantasy High

Score: +2

Miles Gutierrez-Riley

as Fabian Aramaris Seacaster in Fantasy High

Score: 0

Liv Hewson

as Kristen Applebees in Fantasy High

Score: +2

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Riz Gukgak in Fantasy High

Score: +4

Brian Altemus

as Michael Munroe in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Matthew Taylor in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Isabela Merced

as Jessica Riley in Until Dawn

Score: 0

Sabrina Carpenter

as Jessica Riley in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Brianne Tju

as Emily Davis in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Kiernan Shipka

as Samantha Giddings in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Malia Pyles

as Ashley Brown in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Mia Isaac

as Ashley Brown in Until Dawn

Score: -1

Jeffrey Combs

as Dr. Alan Hill in Until Dawn

Score: +1

Erin Moriarty

as Samantha Giddings in Until Dawn

Score: -1